Aftermath - when the boys came home

Thursday 9 September 2010

Recent Additions
   & Updates
Search the site


Site Information
Resources

 

News clips

from The Observer Sunday 12 March 2000

Indian veterans wounded by 'racist' halt to parade
by Tracy McVeigh

Brighton memorialRemains of plastic poppy wreaths and ribbon lie scattered amid the brambles that almost reach the blue steps of a white marble temple. High on the slope of a South Downs valley, the building could be mistaken for a landowner's folly but is possibly Britain's only reminder of the 64,000 Indians who died fighting in the First World War.

For more than 50 years British war veterans have made an annual pilgrimage to the site, a mile out of Brighton, but the 30ft memorial now seems condemned to fall into ruin.

This year, amid accusations of racism and small-mindedness, the veterans have called a halt, saying members are too old to trek across the field that separates the Chattri memorial from the road.

The Royal British Legion has organised the service, on the last Sunday in June, since 1943. Local and national dignitaries are invited and the Undivided Indian Ex-Services Association busses in veterans from around the country.

The legion decided to end the event without consulting Asian veterans or community groups, provoking anger from families whose fathers and grandfathers sacrificed their lives for a nation they believe is now forgetting them.

The Chattri was built in 1921 and unveiled by the then Prince of Wales. Two slabs of granite below its steps cover the concrete where up to 20 Sikh and Hindu soldiers were burnt on funeral pyres.

One was the father of 89-year-old Colonel Assa Singh, a Second World War British Army veteran who has attended the ceremony every year since 1943. Deeply upset that it is to be abandoned, he said that to forget Chattri would be to forget the men who gave their lives.

Indian soldiers wounded in France were brought to Brighton and taken to a hospital set up at the King's request at the Royal Pavilion. Muslims who died were taken to Woking for burial, and Sikhs and Hindus were cre mated in the Sussex countryside.

The ending of the Chattri service is seen as another blow to a community that feels ignored by history.

'It is straightforward racism,' said Santush Kanwar of the Undivided Indian Ex-Services Association. 'There was always a fuss over whether we should bring so many people. The British Legion would be fussing about how they were going to make us all tea. For goodness sake, it wasn't about tea!'

The father and grandfather of Harmander Singh, an adviser to the British Asian Volunteer Action group, fought in the British Army in two world wars but as Commonwealth soldiers their war pensions were well below that of a white British soldier.

'Future generations need to be proud to be British and to know our ancestors gave up their lives for this country. This memorial may seem insignificant but it is very important.'

Many local Asians resent the fact that it may now fall to them to look after Chattri. Singh said one woman had told him: 'We have already given our lives, why should we dip into our pockets too.'

Imam Sajid, secretary of the Brighton Ethnic Minorities Representative Council, added: 'If the British Legion cannot organise it, then they should have talked to us.'

Derek Bollom, branch secretary of the British Legion at Patcham, was surprised by the outrage. 'We decided not to do it this year because it is just too difficult to maintain, what with trying to organise the tea afterwards.'

'It's not that we want to forget them. We're getting old, our membership is shrinking.'

 

Back to News Clips Contents

Member of the History Channel
visit aftermath books
In association with Amazon